Sooner or later your defense attorney sends you the plaintiff's expert report. The usual advice is to read it closely and flag what is wrong. That advice is correct, and it stops one step short of being useful, because nobody says how.
Most physicians respond with a long, angry email. Counsel reads it, agrees with the feeling, and can use almost none of it.
What counsel can use is a list of the report's factual statements, each one checked against the page of the record it depends on. You know the chart, the unit, the abbreviations and the workflow better than anyone else on the defense side. This article describes how to turn that knowledge into something your attorney can put in front of an expert, a witness or a judge.
It is general information, not legal advice. Do this work only as your defense counsel directs.
Work from the copy counsel gives you. Do not open the patient's chart in the electronic record to do this. Access is logged, and a defendant reading the chart after suit is filed invites questions that have nothing to do with the care. The produced, page-numbered set is also the only version that matters, because it is the one the expert was given.
Ask counsel how to send your notes. Whether your written notes are protected depends on how and to whom they are written, and the rules differ by state. Ask first. Ask which email account to use as well.
Report facts. "The expert is wrong about the standard of care" is an opinion, and your own expert will give it. "The report says the lactate was drawn at 14:00, and the record on page 212 shows it was collected at 11:42" is a fact that anyone can verify.
Go through the report and number every statement about what happened. Leave the opinions for later.
A report contains three kinds of statement:
Only the first kind can be checked against the chart. The other two rest on it. An opinion built on a wrong time or a wrong value loses its footing when the fact is corrected, and it is counsel and your expert who decide how to use that.
Next to each numbered fact, write the source the expert cites. If the expert cites none, write "no cite". Those are often the first ones to check.
For every numbered statement, find the page. Write down four things: the page number, the time on the entry, who wrote it, and the words used.
Use the chart's words, not your memory of the day. If the record does not contain the fact at all, write that down. An expert's statement with nothing behind it in the record is a finding.
1. The wrong clock. A chart carries several times for one event: when an order was placed, when a specimen was collected, when a result was posted, when a drug was given, and when a note was filed. An expert who reads the filing time of a note as the time of the examination can move an event by hours.
2. The wrong author. A nurse's entry is attributed to the physician, a resident's note to the attending, or a consultant's recommendation to the doctor who received it. Check who signed each entry the report relies on.
3. Carried-forward text. A finding that was copied from the previous day's note is treated as that day's examination. The reverse also happens: a new finding is dismissed as copied text when it was freshly documented.
4. The wrong encounter. A value, an image or a finding is taken from a different visit or admission and placed in the one at issue. This is common when a patient has several admissions close together.
5. What was known at the time. A final radiology read, a culture result or a pathology report is treated as available when the decision was made. Compare the time of the result with the time of the decision.
6. What was left out. The normal examination, the documented conversation, the refusal, the return precautions or the consult that was requested may be in the record and absent from the report. List each one with its page.
7. Records the expert did not review. Compare the expert's list of materials with what was produced. Nursing flowsheets, the medication administration record, outside records, earlier admissions and the images themselves are the usual gaps. An opinion about monitoring written without the flowsheets is worth knowing about.
8. Quotation and paraphrase. Check every quotation against the page. Look for a sentence cut in half, and for a paraphrase that is stronger than the original. Do the same for testimony: compare what the report says a witness testified to with the page and line of the transcript.
Put the results in a table with one row per statement.
| # | Expert's statement (report page) | What the record shows | Record page | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | "No neurological examination was documented on the evening of the 3rd" (p. 6) | Examination documented by the night resident at 21:14: strength and sensation recorded for all four limbs | 318 | Left out |
| 9 | "The potassium on admission was 6.1" (p. 8) | Admission potassium 4.9. The 6.1 value was collected on hospital day 3 | 77, 141 | Wrong encounter or date |
Keep the entries short and neutral. Leave out adjectives. Counsel will supply the argument, and a plain table is easier to hand to your expert.
Add a second, shorter list: the statements that are accurate and that hurt. Your attorney needs these more than the errors. A weakness that counsel hears about from you can be prepared for. One that comes out for the first time at your deposition cannot.
An expert's opinion has to rest on the facts of the case. When the facts in a report are wrong, counsel has material for cross-examination, and in some courts for a challenge to the opinion itself. The standards for that challenge are covered in Bulletproofing Your Med-Mal Expert Report Under the Amended FRE 702, written from the expert's side.
The table also changes how you prepare. A physician who has checked every factual statement against the page walks into a deposition knowing where the report is solid and where it is not.
This is the same work a legal nurse consultant does on an opposing report, and it is slow by hand. MedLegal AI reads the full record and cites every finding to its page, so the comparison starts from a page-referenced chronology. You can see a finished sample case with each finding linked to its source document, or read about the fixed-fee physician records review for defense firms and claims teams.
Litigation records are held under your firm's protective orders and agreements. A defendant physician should not upload them anywhere. That decision belongs to counsel.
Checking a report against a record is the core skill of case review. Physicians who do it well are in demand on both sides. A Practicing Physician's Guide to Expert Witness Work describes what the work involves, and the expert network takes applications for paid case review.
Yes, as defense counsel directs. The defendant physician usually knows the chart, the unit and the workflow better than anyone else on the defense side. The useful contribution is a check of the report's factual statements against the produced record, page by page.
Do not open the electronic chart for that purpose. Electronic records log who opened a chart and when, and that log can be requested in discovery. Work from the page-numbered copy your attorney gives you, which is also the version the expert was given. If the patient is still under your care, you open the chart to treat them, and you tell your attorney you are still treating.
Eight kinds: the wrong time for an event, the wrong author of an entry, text carried forward from an earlier note, a value or finding taken from a different encounter, results treated as known before they were available, documented findings that were left out, records the expert did not review, and quotations or paraphrases that do not match the page.
It depends on the state and on how and to whom the notes are written. Ask your defense attorney before you write anything, including which email account to use, and send your notes only to your attorney.
For defense counsel and nurse consultants: the sample case shows a completed work-up beside the six documents it was written from, with each document mention linked to its source. It is a fictional record, and nothing is uploaded to view it.
Open the sample case →Sources. This article describes a working method and cites no outside studies. The sample table rows are illustrations written for this article and are not taken from any case. Statements about privilege, discovery of access logs and challenges to expert opinions are general; the rules differ by state and court, and your defense counsel’s direction governs.
MedLegal AI is software, not a law firm. This article is general information for physicians, attorneys and legal nurse consultants; it is not legal or medical advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Rules on reporting, privilege and discovery differ by state and change over time. Your defense counsel’s advice about your case governs. Questions: [email protected]