High-Low Agreements and the NPDB: When the Low Payment Is Reported

By John Mahoney · November 16, 2026 · About 7 minutes

Is a payment under a high-low agreement reported to the NPDB? Under the NPDB Guidebook, a payment at the low end of a high-low agreement is not reported if the fact-finder (a judge, jury or arbitrator) rules for the defendant and assigns no liability to the practitioner. It is reported in every other case: a verdict against the practitioner for any amount, a settlement reached before the verdict, and a proceeding that decided only the amount of damages. This is general information, not legal advice.
On this page
  1. What a high-low agreement is
  2. Why a low payment after a defense verdict is not reported
  3. The Guidebook's four examples
  4. How the exception is lost
  5. What an unreported payment does not settle
  6. Questions to ask before the agreement is made
  7. After the verdict
  8. The trade you are making
  9. Questions and answers

The jury has the case. Your attorney steps into the hallway to take a call from the claims representative and comes back with a proposal: a high-low agreement. You have a few minutes to understand it. Most physicians hear the term for the first time at exactly this point.

The question that follows is always the same. If I win and my insurer pays the plaintiff anyway, does that go to the Data Bank?

What a high-low agreement is

It is a contract made before the decision that sets a floor and a ceiling on what the plaintiff will receive. The Guidebook describes it as an agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant's insurer.

Take a low of $100,000 and a high of $900,000.

The insurer buys a cap on its loss. The plaintiff buys a guaranteed recovery. You are the named defendant, and the verdict still carries your name.

Why a low payment after a defense verdict is not reported

The NPDB collects reports of payments made for the benefit of a practitioner to settle or satisfy a written malpractice claim or judgment. The Guidebook's reasoning is that a low-end payment after a finding of no liability is a different kind of payment. It is made under what the Guidebook calls an "independent contract between the defendant's insurer and the plaintiff", and the claim against the practitioner was decided in the practitioner's favor.

That reasoning has one requirement. Someone with authority to decide liability has to decide it, and has to decide it for you.

The Guidebook's four examples

The Guidebook works through four cases. They are summarized here with its figures.

What happenedReported?Amount reported
Low $50,000, high $200,000. The jury finds the physician liable and awards $40,000. The insurer pays $50,000 because of the agreement.Yes$40,000. The additional $10,000 is explained in the report's narrative.
Low $50,000, high $150,000. An arbitrator finds for the practitioner with no liability. The insurer pays the $50,000 low.NoNone
Low $50,000, high $150,000. Before the verdict comes back, the parties settle for $100,000.Yes$100,000
Low $50,000, high $200,000. The parties go to binding arbitration to set the amount of damages only. The arbitrator awards $80,000.Yes$80,000

The first example surprises people. The jury's award was below the low, the plaintiff received the low, and the payment is still reported, because the jury found liability.

The fourth example is the one to remember when someone proposes a faster route than trial. An arbitration that sets damages without deciding liability produces no finding in your favor, so the payment is treated as a settlement.

How the exception is lost

  1. The case settles before the verdict. A high-low agreement that is in place does not change the duty to report a settlement payment. Once the parties settle, the agreement no longer governs.
  2. The fact-finder rules against you. Any payment made for your benefit after a finding of liability is reported, whatever the agreement says and however small the award.
  3. Liability is never decided. A proceeding limited to damages does not qualify.
  4. There is no ruling for the defendant. The Guidebook's text requires a ruling in the defendant's favor that assigns no liability. Its examples do not cover a mistrial or a jury that cannot reach a verdict. If your case ends that way, ask counsel how the carrier will treat any payment that follows.

Also note that there is no minimum amount. The Guidebook states that the size of a payment is irrelevant to whether it is reported.

What an unreported payment does not settle

A low payment that stays out of the NPDB can still appear elsewhere.

Questions to ask before the agreement is made

You may have ten minutes. These are the questions worth using them on.

  1. Does my policy require my consent to this agreement, or can the carrier enter it without me?
  2. What are the low and the high, and is the high within my policy limits?
  3. Does the agreement cover every defendant or only me?
  4. Does it waive appeal and post-trial motions, and for which side?
  5. If the jury finds for me and the carrier pays the low, will the carrier report that payment to the NPDB? Ask for the answer in writing.
  6. What does my state require the carrier or me to report to the medical board in that situation?
  7. How will the payment appear in my claims history with this carrier?

After the verdict

If the jury found for you and the low was paid, confirm the result. A practitioner can query their own NPDB record. Payers have 30 days from a payment to file a report, so run the query after that window has passed and keep the response with your case file.

If a report was filed that you believe the rule does not require, the NPDB has a dispute process, and the first step is with the entity that filed the report. That process is described in The NPDB Report: What Actually Gets Reported When a Claim Resolves.

The trade you are making

A high-low agreement removes the worst outcome and the best one together. A verdict above the high can no longer reach you, and a clean defense verdict now comes with a payment to the plaintiff. Whether that trade is right depends on how the trial has gone, what your limits are, and what your counsel has seen in that courtroom. Those are judgments for you and your attorney. The reporting question should not be part of the uncertainty, because the rule is written down.

Questions and answers

Is a payment under a high-low agreement reported to the NPDB?

Under the NPDB Guidebook, a low-end payment is not reported if the fact-finder (a judge, jury or arbitrator) rules for the defendant and assigns no liability to the practitioner. A payment is reported if the practitioner is found liable, if the case settles before a verdict, or if the proceeding decided only the amount of damages.

What if the jury finds the physician liable but awards less than the low?

The payment is reported. In the Guidebook example, the low was $50,000 and the jury found the physician liable and awarded $40,000. The $40,000 is reported, and the additional $10,000 paid because of the agreement is explained in the narrative of the report.

What if the case settles while a high-low agreement is in place?

The settlement payment is reported. The NPDB Guidebook states that the existence of a high-low agreement does not change the requirement to report a settlement payment.

Does the physician have to consent to a high-low agreement?

That depends on the insurance policy. The NPDB Guidebook describes a high-low agreement as a contract between the plaintiff and the defendant's insurer. Ask defense counsel and the carrier, before trial, whether your policy requires your consent.

How you testify comes before any of this

A high-low agreement is proposed when the defense is unsure of the verdict. How the defendant physician testifies is a large part of that. Survive Your Deposition is a course for physician defendants with a practice examiner, built to be used alongside your defense attorney.

See how the course works →

Sources. NPDB Guidebook, Chapter E, Reporting Medical Malpractice Payments, section “High-Low Agreements” (Health Resources and Services Administration), read November 16, 2026. The rule, the four examples and the statement that payment size is irrelevant are taken from that page; one phrase is quoted. The 30-day reporting period is from the same chapter. State medical-board reporting laws were not reviewed for this article. NPDB requirements are set by federal law and regulation and can change; the current Guidebook is the controlling text.

MedLegal AI is software, not a law firm. This article is general information for physicians, attorneys and legal nurse consultants; it is not legal or medical advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Rules on reporting, privilege and discovery differ by state and change over time. Your defense counsel’s advice about your case governs. Questions: [email protected]