Comparison · Updated May 2, 2026

MedLegal AI vs CoCounsel (Casetext) for Plaintiff Med-Mal Firms

CoCounsel finds cases. MedLegal AI builds the case. They sit on Westlaw's editorial library. We sit on the workflow that decides whether you sign the retainer.

Casetext was acquired by Thomson Reuters in 2023; the standalone product was sunset on March 31, 2025. The CoCounsel name now lives inside the broader Westlaw bundle. It's a strong general-purpose legal research tool. Plaintiff medical-malpractice firms have a different problem — and a different budget.

Start your 14-day free trial — no credit card See pricing

TL;DR

Side-by-side feature comparison

Feature CoCounsel MedLegal AI
Daubert / expert-vulnerability workup
9-source witness research (NPI, state board, SEC, news, social, academic, etc.)Partial
Specialty-specific standard-of-care templates (OB, ER, anesthesia, surgery)
Causation chain tied to peer-reviewed literature
Medical chronology / record summarizationGeneral
Demand letter drafter (med-mal-shaped)
Deposition outline generator✓ (general)✓ (specialty-aware)
50-state SOL calculator
Medicare / Medicaid lien math
Massive case-law corpus (Westlaw editorial)
KeyCite citation checking
Document review at e-discovery scalePer-case
Embedded AI assistant ("chat with case")
Specialty-trained for plaintiff med-mal
Pricing modelPer-seat / annualFlat firm-wide / month

Pricing comparison

CoCounsel (Thomson Reuters)
~$225–$500 / user / month
$1,125–$2,500/mo
Estimated all-in for a 5-lawyer firm. CoCounsel Core ~$225/seat, All Access ~$500/seat. Some enterprise bundles tracked at $900/seat. Westlaw bundles run ~$428/seat. Pricing is heavily negotiated and not published; figures from third-party trackers. Annual contracts; per-task add-ons start at $75/task.
MedLegal AI
$49 / $99 / $249 / $499 — firm-wide
$99–$499/mo
Same price whether the firm has 1 lawyer or 25. Courtroom AI add-on $99/$299. 14-day free trial — no credit card. No annual lock-in.

3 reasons MedLegal AI wins for plaintiff med-mal

1. Built for the moment you sign or decline the retainer

CoCounsel assumes you have a case and need research. MedLegal AI is designed for the upstream decision: "Is this a case?" Daubert feasibility, expert vetting, SOL, and lien math are first-class workflows — not generic deposition outlines. That intake-stage evaluation is the workflow plaintiff med-mal actually runs.

2. Med-mal-specific, not segment-agnostic

Specialty standard-of-care templates (OB, ER, anesthesia, surgery), causation chains tied to peer-reviewed literature, NPI lookups, state medical-board sanction checks — none of that is in CoCounsel because CoCounsel serves every practice area. We serve one. The whole 23-tool surface is tuned for plaintiff med-mal.

3. Contingency-economics pricing

CoCounsel is priced per seat for hourly-billing firms. A 5-lawyer plaintiff firm pays roughly $1,125–$2,500/mo for CoCounsel before Westlaw bundling. MedLegal AI is $99–$499/mo flat, regardless of headcount — the economic shape contingency practices want.

Where CoCounsel might be the better fit

If your firm lives in Westlaw

If your work depends on deep case-law research across federal and 50-state corpora, KeyCite citation checking, and e-discovery-grade document review, CoCounsel sits on top of decades of Thomson Reuters editorial infrastructure. We don't compete with Westlaw on case-law breadth and don't try to. Plaintiff med-mal firms that need both can — and often do — run CoCounsel for research alongside MedLegal AI for case-building.

Try MedLegal AI free for 14 days

Full access to all 23 tools. No credit card. No setup fees. Cancel anytime.

Start your 14-day free trial Compare plans