Comparison Matrix · Built April 25, 2026 · Updated October 29, 2026
EvenUp vs Supio vs Filevine vs Harvey vs CoCounsel: 13-Feature Matrix (2026)
A 13-feature, 6-vendor comparison of MedLegal AI Courtroom AI vs EvenUp, Supio, Filevine, Harvey, and CoCounsel. Built from public sources only — vendor websites, G2, Capterra, LawNext, LawSites, and Artificial Lawyer. No NDA materials.
By John Mahoney · 9-minute read · Updated October 29, 2026 · Competitor data as of our April 25, 2026 review
Verify it yourself — free, no login
See how AI medical-record review links every fact to the exact Bates page that proves it — click any citation and jump straight to the record.
See the 60-second demo →
Updated October 29, 2026. This page is a point-in-time matrix. Every competitor cell below reflects what was publicly advertised as of our April 25, 2026 review; we have not re-verified individual vendor features or prices since then, and vendors in this space change both frequently. The methodology (public sources only, question marks where we could not verify, honest losses stated) is unchanged. We added the FAQ at the end and removed a link to a data file that is no longer published.
Why this matrix exists
If you're a plaintiff or litigation lawyer evaluating AI tools in 2026, you've probably noticed every single comparison page on the internet is written by one of the vendors. We're no exception — MedLegal AI is one of the six tools in this matrix. So this is biased by definition. We've tried to keep it honest by following three rules:
- Public-source-only. A cell is marked ✓ only if the vendor publicly advertises the feature on their own site or it appears in a reputable third-party review (G2, Capterra, LawSites, LawNext, Artificial Lawyer). If we couldn't verify, we marked ?.
- Honest losses. There are entire columns where we lose. Filevine has matter management we don't ship. Harvey has BigLaw research depth we can't match. CoCounsel has Westlaw. We say so plainly below the table.
- Freshness signal. Competitor cells reflect what was publicly advertised as of our April 25, 2026 review and have not been individually re-verified since. Legal AI features change weekly. If something is wrong, email [email protected] and we'll fix it within 48 hours.
The matrix
✓ publicly advertised
∼ partial / via prompt
× not advertised
? couldn't verify
| Feature |
MedLegal AI |
EvenUp |
Supio |
Filevine |
Harvey |
CoCounsel |
| Public flat-rate pricing[1] |
✓ |
× |
× |
∼ |
× |
∼ |
| Live deposition transcription (during depo)[2] |
✓ |
× |
✓ |
✓ |
× |
× |
| Real-time citation verification during testimony[3] |
✓ |
× |
× |
× |
× |
× |
| Real-time contradiction / impeachment flagging[4] |
✓ |
× |
✓ |
✓ |
× |
× |
| CMS Open Payments lookup (industry $ to expert)[5] |
✓ |
× |
× |
× |
× |
× |
| NIH RePORTER grant lookup[5] |
✓ |
× |
× |
× |
× |
× |
| Prior-deposition / testimony pull (CourtListener)[6] |
✓ |
× |
∼ |
× |
∼ |
✓ |
| Automated 14-section Daubert memo (.docx + PDF)[7] |
✓ |
× |
× |
× |
∼ |
∼ |
| Multi-witness concurrent sessions[8] |
✓ |
× |
? |
? |
× |
× |
| AI-drafted demand letter (PI)[9] |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
∼ |
∼ |
| Practice / matter management[10] |
× |
× |
∼ |
✓ |
× |
× |
| Westlaw / LexisNexis integration[11] |
× |
× |
× |
× |
✓ |
✓ |
| Med-mal / nursing-home / birth-injury tuning[12] |
✓ |
× |
× |
∼ |
× |
× |
Where MedLegal AI loses
If we pretended this matrix was a clean sweep, you wouldn't trust the rest. Here's where each competitor genuinely beats us:
- Filevine wins on case management. If you need a single system of record for matters, intake, calendaring, billing, and document storage — that's Filevine's home turf, not ours. We don't ship matter management and we don't plan to.
- Harvey wins on BigLaw transactional research. If you're an Am Law 200 firm doing M&A due diligence at scale, Harvey + Vault is the right tool. With LexisNexis baked in since June 2025, Harvey now has access to a "must-have" proprietary research library we don't and won't.
- CoCounsel wins on Westlaw integration. If your firm has been on Westlaw for fifteen years and you want AI that grounds answers in real Westlaw cites, CoCounsel is the obvious upgrade path. We don't have a Thomson Reuters partnership.
- EvenUp wins on Expert-Reviewed demand-letter quality. Their human-in-the-loop drafter review tier produces letters polished beyond what any pure-AI workflow ships. If you do 200+ PI demands a year and quality > price, EvenUp is credible.
- Supio wins on PI case-prep breadth. If your case mix is 100% PI and you're already on MyCase or CasePeer, Supio's automatic case sync + Instant Ledger billing rollup is more polished than anything we ship for PI specifically.
Where MedLegal AI wins
The legitimate moat — the place we genuinely have something nobody else publicly advertises — sits in three rows of the matrix above:
- Real-time citation verification. When a defense expert says "I rely on Smith et al. 2019 for that opinion," our system pulls Smith 2019 from PubMed inside the depo and shows you whether it actually says what they claim. No competitor in this matrix advertises this. It's the difference between catching a fabricated cite at the depo (settlement leverage) versus catching it three weeks later (post-hoc memo).
- Multi-source Daubert workup. CMS Open Payments + NIH RePORTER + SEC Form 4 + IRS Form 990 + state medical boards + Medicare practice profile — that combination of public datasets, queried in one sweep against a witness name, is genuinely unique. Harvey and CoCounsel can synthesize memos if you feed them the data. We pull the data ourselves and then synthesize.
- The combination during a live deposition. Supio and Filevine ship live transcription with contradiction flagging — that's table stakes now. The combination of live transcription + multi-source bias research + citation verification running concurrently is the unique offering. Other tools do one or two of those legs. We do all three in a single session.
Closing — who should pick which tool
BigLaw transactional / M&AHarvey. Vault for due diligence, LexisNexis for research. Don't overthink it.
Westlaw firm, mid-to-largeCoCounsel. You're already paying TR. Add the agentic layer.
PI shop with intake bottleneckEvenUp (volume, Express tier) or Supio (full lifecycle, MyCase/CasePeer integration).
Multi-practice firm needing matter managementFilevine. Case management first, AI bolt-ons second. Watch the support reviews.
Mid-size plaintiff med-mal / nursing-home / birth-injuryMedLegal AI. Specialty-tuned analysis + live-depo Daubert workup is what we built for.
Solo or small firm under $5K/mo budgetMedLegal AI ($49–$499 flat) or Filevine's entry tier (pricing as listed on their site at our April 2026 review). EvenUp, Harvey, and CoCounsel did not publish flat pricing at that time.
Honest take: If you're a plaintiff lawyer doing 2+ depositions a week against retained medical experts, the live citation-verify + CMS Open Payments combination is genuinely the thing nobody else ships. If you're doing transactional work or BigLaw litigation, Harvey or CoCounsel is the better tool. Pick the one your case mix actually points to — there's no single winner across all six columns of this table.
Start 14-Day Free Trial
See Courtroom AI Live
Frequently asked questions
How was this comparison matrix built?
From public sources only, as of our April 25, 2026 review: vendor websites plus third-party reviews on G2, Capterra, LawSites, LawNext, and Artificial Lawyer. A feature is marked as a check only when the vendor publicly advertised it or a reputable review described it at that time; cells we could not verify are marked with a question mark. No NDA materials were used, and MedLegal AI is one of the six tools, so the matrix is disclosed as vendor-authored.
Which tools does the matrix compare, and on what features?
Six tools: MedLegal AI, EvenUp, Supio, Filevine, Harvey, and CoCounsel, scored on 13 features including public flat-rate pricing, live deposition transcription, real-time citation verification during testimony, contradiction flagging, CMS Open Payments and NIH RePORTER lookups, prior-testimony pull, a structured Daubert memo, multi-witness sessions, demand-letter drafting, matter management, Westlaw or LexisNexis integration, and medical-specialty tuning.
Where do the other tools beat MedLegal AI?
The post says so plainly. As of the April 2026 review, Filevine led on matter management, Harvey on BigLaw transactional research with LexisNexis access, CoCounsel on Westlaw integration, EvenUp on expert-reviewed demand-letter quality, and Supio on PI case-prep breadth with practice-management integrations. MedLegal AI does not ship matter management or a Westlaw or LexisNexis integration.
Is the information in this comparison still current?
Treat every competitor cell as a snapshot from April 25, 2026. Legal AI features and pricing change quickly, and we have not re-verified each vendor claim since that date. The MedLegal AI column reflects our own product. If you spot a competitor feature we marked as not advertised that has since shipped, email the address in the footer and we will correct the matrix.
Related: what the record actually supports
See the AI cite its source — no login
Most legal AI is wrong 17–33% of the time. Watch MedLegal AI pin every finding to the exact record page — click any citation and it jumps to the line that proves it.
Watch the 30-second demo →